Last updated at 12:36 AM. Monday 15 March 2010

Go to comments July 07, 2009

Dian Ariffahmi

Bottles of alcoholic beverages at the West Jakarta mayor’s office last month. Tens of thousands of the bottles were seized in raids between April and May this year, then destroyed. (Photo: Safir Makki, JG)

Bottles of alcoholic beverages at the West Jakarta mayor’s office last month. Tens of thousands of the bottles were seized in raids between April and May this year, then destroyed. (Photo: Safir Makki, JG)

Alcohol: Why Indonesia Isn’t Producing Enough (And How to Fix That)

Indonesia tops a lot of global lists: It is the world’s largest archipelago; it has the world’s largest Muslim population; and, unknown to many, it is also one of the largest importers of alcoholic beverages.

That might explain why a senior member of the Indonesian Chamber of Commerce and Industry (Kadin) urged the central government on Monday to allow foreign investment into the country’s alcohol production sector, saying that keeping it on the “negative investment” list only increased the country’s dependence on imported alcohol.

The government is currently preparing a presidential decree on a newly revised negative investment list, which it is expected to share with industry groups on Saturday for comment.

Maxi Gunawan, head of Kadin’s committee for Europe, said Indonesia was already the sixth largest importer of alcohol in the world by volume, just behind Thailand.

“Now we are importing 100 million bottles a year. It’s much more efficient if we can produce them here,” he said.

The inclusion of alcohol on the negative investment list is more political than economic, Maxi said, and opening up the industry will mean less import taxes to distributors and bring additional benefits, such as new jobs.

Beer manufacturers PT Multi Bintang Indonesia and PT Delta Djakarta, which produces Anker beer, are the sole alcohol producers on the stock exchange and cannot meet domestic demand.

But Muhammad Lutfi, chairman of the Indonesian Investment Coordinating Board, said it would be hard to open up the industry because it had been on a government “black list” of products and services deemed detrimental to society, such as gambling, since 1994. “It’s still closed [to investment], and there is no way that it will be opened,” Lutfi said, noting that it could spark protests from the country’s Muslims.

“Even if we exclude that industry from the list, I think alcoholic beverages would not grow as fast as other industries,” Lutfi said, adding that local producers were not even presently operating at maximum capacity.



Post a comment

Login or register to post comments!

Comments

Tanamur

11:39 PM July 9, 2009

Yes Walkyrie, Bali is producing wine. It did start more than 10 years ago. It was alrady possible to drink so Hatten rosé there.

Since this time we can now find some red and white wine.

The rose wine is frankly good and can compare to most of the foreign rose wines which is sold in Jakarta more than 3 times its price.

Althought finding it in Jakarta is very complicated.

Tanamur

10:54 PM July 9, 2009

Alcohol is toxic such as tabac and others. I cant say which one are the worst.

Lets start banning all toxic substance and probably start by banning metro mini from Jakarta.

Overall I heard that to bring alcohol in jakarta is not so complicated. Fees in airport is around 50 000 per bottle.

Now looking at some serious study, we can see that have a glass of wine everyday is good for the health.

So far I have not seen any study showing that tabacco was good for health.

I will not comment about metro mini ;)

M.M.A.

6:15 PM July 9, 2009

Alcoholic beverages have toxic potentials. In my opinion, these products should be condemned in this country.

Valkyrie

4:45 PM July 9, 2009

Guys! Try read the 8th June issue of Newsweek. In it there is an article about someone having a store selling liquor, in Iraq. The other day I way watching Al Jazeera showing how the Kurds are taking great risks in smuggling liquor into Iran.

As I have already commented. Alcohol is a commodity where the government can generate revenue from. Just look at the number of cigarette manufacturers in Indonesia.

Perhaps Bir Bintang likes to enjoy being the only producer? Isn't there a law against monopoly?

Bali is now producing Wine although not of international quality but it's a start.

Valkyrie

8:06 AM July 9, 2009

Alcohol is also a trade commodity like tobacco. Both are considered "Haram" and harmful to health. Why so much fuss over alcohol and not tobacco?

I agree with Tikno......Ban it totally or allow it freely.

LLast word........... one can find alcohol flowing quite ffreely in certain Middle East countries.

Valkyrie

6:50 AM July 9, 2009

Simon, although I am compelled to agree with you, I still would ike to try make an effort to rid the nation of this vile disease. I will continue to post comments and hope that those who are willing to read it will search their conscience.

I always wonder at the audacity of these corruptors who are able to face their Almighty daily and yet continue to perpetuate their evil deeds without shame. Indeed, corruption is the cornerstone of this nation.

Perhaps a radical law that locks these "rats" in jail and throw away the keys would be workable? Ha! Ha!

Simon

5:49 PM July 8, 2009

Sadly Valkyrie, such a Fatwa will likely never come. Corruption is the cornerstone of the nation and the relevant authorities would be nothing without it.

tikno

2:53 PM July 8, 2009

Closed to investment? But allowing import?

A dilemma between economic interest and morality. It's hard to find its middle point because there is no direct relationship. Just choose, allow or not at all, so no confusing.

gogox

2:15 PM July 7, 2009

What's really problem on alcoholic beverages? Why even the government always take hard stand to raid the alcoholic stuff, there are no improvement on the attitude on stopping the distribution of this material. I think it's interesting if we are back to cynical Javanese metaphor on human life as, " life is merely coming a moment for having a drink". In its cultural richness, traditional alcoholic beverages become part of rites. So, we should accommodate the original values on this matter, not just blindly taken for granted with certain value reference which could violate the basic right of the people.

Pinko

12:35 PM July 7, 2009

dear morality police... domestic alcohol manufacturing will not force you to drink and will probably not change the number of people who choose to drink alcohol in the country, it will just reduce imports and be good for employment. they should manufacture a commercial version of arak and export it... it could become a boutique drink overseas and also a souvenir for tourists to take home.

Valkyrie

8:01 AM July 7, 2009

Let's have religious concerns across the board. Corruption is also "haram" but it rarely generates appropriate attention from the relevant authorities. I am waiting for the day when a Fatwa will be issued against corruption. Can this be possible?