Last updated at 2:24 AM. Saturday 20 March 2010

Go to comments December 01, 2009

Jakarta Globe

From left, Mark Leonard Winter, Thomas Wright and Gyton Grantley as Tony Stewart, Brian Peters and Gary Cunningham, portraying three of the Balibo Five in new film. (Photo courtesy of Balibo Films Pty.)

From left, Mark Leonard Winter, Thomas Wright and Gyton Grantley as Tony Stewart, Brian Peters and Gary Cunningham, portraying three of the Balibo Five in new film. (Photo courtesy of Balibo Films Pty.)

Australian Film ‘Balibo’ Banned by Indonesian Censors

The local premiere of the acclaimed Australian film, “Balibo,” which recounts the murder of five journalists allegedly at the hands of Indonesian soldiers during the 1975 invasion of East Timor, was stopped on Tuesday after the censorship board banned the movie.

The Jakarta Foreign Correspondents Club had planned to show the film for the first time in Indonesia to a private audience at the Blitz Megaplex in the Grand Indonesia Mall.

But a few minutes after the 7 p.m. screening time had passed, JFCC President Jason Tedjasukmana emerged from the screening room to tell a crowd of about 100 journalists and other invited guests, “We have some bad news. The LSF [Film Censorship Agency] officially banned it today.”

The film had been submitted to the LSF by the Jakarta International Film Festival (Jiffest), which had planned to screen the film during the festival, which begins on Friday. The censors reviewed the film Tuesday afternoon, according to Tedjasukmana, and news of the ban was relayed to the journalists’ group by Jiffest officials.

Nauval Yazid, Jiffest’s manager, said that while the censors gave no official reason for the ban, the festival would abide by the ruling.

“They told us that we cannot show the movie,” he said. “The reason was not really clear. It is likely because of concerns that it will affect relations with East Timor and Australia.”

As with all films shown publicly in the country, the festival’s organizers are required to submit all entries to the LSF for approval before screening. Nauval said “Balibo” was added to this year’s line-up because the festival thought it was an important film that ought to be seen by Indonesian audiences.

Pudji Rahayu, the head of the LSF secretariat, refused to comment on the ban when contacted by the Jakarta Globe.

JFCC board members debated whether to press ahead with the screening despite the ban, but were dissuaded after lawyers told them they could face criminal charges for defying the ban.

“Even though this is a private screening, it is in a public place,” Tedjasukmana, a correspondent for Time magazine, said. “There is a very high risk in showing a banned film in a public place.”

The film tells the story of five journalists who were killed in the tiny border town of Balibo when it was taken over by Indonesian forces in October 1975. The so-called Balibo Five, according to official government accounts, died in crossfire.

Asked about the ban following Tuesday’s announcement, freelance journalist and well-known press freedom activist Ezki Suyanto was seething. “This is ridiculous,” she said. “They [the censors] cannot accept reality.”

Given the widespread availability of pirated DVDs, however, it is assumed that copies of the movie will be circulated widely.



Post a comment

Login or register to post comments!

Comments

Valkyrie

10:03 AM December 3, 2009

After you've counted all the stars in the galaxy...then perhaps the truth might emerge!

Has the TRUTH ever been told about the assasination of the seven army officers - lubang buaya!

I am even not that optimistic about the current Bank Century scandal. Yes, there will be a few scapegoats. but......the rest will be history once again!

Wong Edan

9:39 AM December 3, 2009

This is typical of Indonesia's cowardly mercenary army trying to shield the people from the fact that the only "victories" it has ever won have been against unarmed civilians - Java, Bali, North Sumatra 1965, Lampung 1989, Tanjung Priok 1984, Dili 1991, Jakarta 1998 etc etc.

The truth WILL come out one day...

John Ralph

6:17 PM December 2, 2009

Everyone knows the Indonesian military of the day and those politicians are just gutless liars.

padt

4:16 PM December 2, 2009

According to overseas press reports (not reported here in Indonesia) the Indonesian military put pressure on the LSF to ban the film.

"The Indonesian military was instrumental in convincing the LSF to ban the film, which contradicts the official Indonesian explanation that the newsmen were accidentally killed in crossfire." The Age

"Indonesian defence ministry spokesman Slamet Hariyanto today welcomed the ban, saying the film would give Indonesia a bad name and defame its defence force.

"People would ask, what kind of leadership is that, if we ordered journalists to be treated like that?

"This is negative propaganda against Indonesia.'' Brisbane Courier Mail

The film presents a different version of events to what is presented as the official Indonesian version, namely that the journalists were caught in crossfire and died accidentally. The film portrays them as being brutally murdered by Indonesian troops.

I wonder who is telling the truth? Time will tell.